Licking Mat vs Slow Feeder Bowl: Which Should You Choose?

In a nutshell: Licking mats and slow feeder bowls are both interactive feeding tools that provide dog enrichment, but they serve different purposes. A licking mat (or “lick mat”) is best for calming and treating your dog with spreadable goodies in a slow, soothing way, making it great for dog anxiety relief and boredom-busting. A slow feeder bowl, on the other hand, is designed for slow feeding for dogs who gulp their food – it turns mealtime into a puzzle so your pup eats at a safer pace, helping digestion and preventing bloat. Many pet owners use both: a lick mat to occupy and relax their dog during stressful moments, and a slow feeder bowl to improve daily eating habits. Below, we’ll break down the differences, ideal uses, pros and cons, and how to choose the best option for your dog’s age, breed, behavior, and eating style.

Licking Mats for Dogs (Interactive Lick Pads)

What is a licking mat? A licking mat is a flat, textured mat (usually made of rubber or silicone) that you can smear with soft foods for your dog to lick off. The surface has grooves, ridges, and patterns which lock in spreadable treats – making your pup work a bit harder and longer to enjoy their snack. Instead of gulping down a treat in one bite, the dog licks persistently to get every last bit from the crevices. Lick mats come in various shapes (often square or circular) and some even have suction cups to stick on walls or floors. They’re generally flexible, food-safe, and easy to rinse clean. In short, a lick mat turns treat time into a slow, engaging licking activity.

Many lick mats can suction to surfaces. Here a dog calmly licks peanut butter from a mat stuck on the bathtub wall – a smart trick to distract and relax dogs during bath time.

Benefits of Licking Mats

Licking mats pack multiple benefits for dogs, addressing both behavioral and health needs. In fact, lick mats can “soothe, entertain, and enrich” your dog all at once. Here are some key advantages of using a licking mat:

• Calming & anxiety relief: Licking is a naturally soothing behavior for dogs. As they lick, their brain releases pleasure endorphins that help them feel calm and comforted. Many pet parents use lick mats as dog anxiety relief tools – for example, to keep a nervous dog relaxed during fireworks, thunderstorms, grooming, or vet visits. Think of a lick mat as a tasty “pacifier” that can take the edge off stressful situations. Even energetic dogs can use a lick mat after exercise to bring their arousal down and settle calmly.

• Mental enrichment & boredom-busting: Lick mats are a form of interactive dog enrichment. Your dog has to focus and problem-solve slightly to lap up every bit of treat from the textured surface. This engages their brain and can curb boredom or destructive behavior. Any such puzzle-like activity provides mental stimulation, giving your dog a job to do (even if it’s just “how to get the peanut butter out of the corners”). It’s an easy way to enrich your dog’s day, especially when indoor play is limited.

• Slower eating (small portions): While primarily for treats, lick mats do slow down eating. Instead of inhaling a snack in seconds, a dog might spend 10-20 minutes working on a lick mat. If you have a fast eater, using a lick mat for treats – or even for part of their meal – can prevent gobbling and gulping. In fact, some lick mats double as slow feeders to help dogs not “wolf down” their food, reducing risks of choking or bloat from too-rapid eating. A frozen lick mat can slow a dog down even more than some slow feeder bowls, without causing the frustration some puzzles do. (However, note that lick mats typically hold smaller amounts, so they complement rather than replace a slow bowl for large meals.)

• Dental health perks: The act of licking increases saliva production, which can help wash bacteria off the tongue and gums. The mat’s ridges and bristles also scrape gently against the tongue and maybe the front teeth. Some sources claim lick mats can “help clean their teeth” and promote dental health. Important: This is only a minor benefit – lick mats are not a substitute for brushing your dog’s teeth. At best, they can help a bit with freshening the mouth and reducing buildup on the tongue. Always continue regular dental care.

• Positive training and quiet behavior: Lick mats can be used to create positive associations and reward calm behavior. For instance, to help with crate training, you can give a peanut butter-coated lick mat in the crate so the dog sees the crate as a happy, relaxing place. Similarly, you can use a lick mat to redirect a mouthy puppy’s biting habits – when a teething pup is getting nippy or destructive, offering a lick mat can give them a peaceful activity and give you a “few moments of peace”. This teaches puppies to settle down. Overall, having a lick mat in your toolkit is a must for dog enrichment, according to experts.

Ideal Foods to Use on a Lick Mat

One big advantage of lick mats is their versatility with different treats. What can you put on a lick mat? Almost anything that is dog-safe, spreadable or lickable! Here are some favorite options:

• Peanut butter – This is a classic lick mat spread. Most dogs adore peanut butter. Use it in moderation and make sure it does not contain xylitol (an artificial sweetener toxic to dogs). A teaspoon smeared across the mat will go a long way. Choose natural, unsalted peanut butter if possible, and remember it’s a treat (high in calories).

• Yogurt or purees – Plain, unsweetened yogurt (Greek or regular) is another great choice. It’s creamy, low-fat, and contains probiotics that can aid digestion. You can also use pumpkin puree, mashed banana, unsweetened applesauce, cottage cheese, or even baby food (as long as ingredients are dog-friendly). These soft foods spread easily and offer healthy variety.

• Wet dog food – Lick mats aren’t just for treats; you can serve part of your dog’s regular meal on them too. Pâté-style canned dog food or a fresh dog food blend can be smeared into the mat’s grooves. Some people even soften kibble with water and press it into the mat. This effectively turns the lick mat into a slow-feeding plate for dogs who eat too quickly or need extra mental stimulation at mealtime.

• Broth and frozen treats – To really extend the licking session, consider making a frozen lick mat treat. Pour a bit of low-sodium chicken or beef broth onto the mat and freeze it, or freeze a yogurt/PB spread for a couple of hours. The result is an ice-cold “dog popsicle” that can keep your pup busy for ages on a hot day. Freezing not only makes the fun last longer, but also adds a cooling element for teething puppies or summer afternoons.

• Other creative ideas – You can experiment: try spreadable liver paste, dog-safe “squeezy cheese,” canned pumpkin, blended fruit, or even honey (in small amounts, as honey is sweet). Some lick mats are divided into sections, so you could put a different treat in each quadrant to create a tasting platter for your dog. Always ensure any food used is safe for dogs (avoid ingredients like onion, excessive salt, etc.). And remember to adjust meal portions if you’re giving a lot of extra treats on the mat to avoid weight gain.

Cleaning and Safety Tips for Lick Mats

Lick mats are designed to be reusable and easy to clean, but they do have lots of little nooks and crannies. Here’s how to keep things hygienic and safe:

• Wash after each use: It’s best to clean the lick mat promptly once your dog has finished their treat. Even if it looks licked-clean, saliva and food residue can breed bacteria or mold if left sitting. Most quality lick mats are dishwasher-safe (especially those made of food-grade silicone). You can simply toss it on the top rack of the dishwasher. If hand-washing, use warm soapy water and a brush to get into the grooves. For stubborn dried-on bits (like peanut butter), soaking the mat in hot water for a few minutes helps.

• Check material and temperature limits: Ensure your lick mat is labeled food-grade and non-toxic. Cheap off-brand mats might use materials that leach chemicals – so stick to reputable brands. Also verify whether it’s safe for dishwasher, microwave, or boiling. Some silicone mats can handle boiling water sterilization, but others might warp – always follow the manufacturer’s guidelines.

• Supervise your dog: A lick mat is not a chew toy! Many are made of soft flexible rubber or silicone, which a determined dog could tear apart. Never leave a dog unsupervised with a lick mat if they are likely to chew it. Most dogs will be focused on licking the food, but if your pup starts gnawing on the mat’s edges or tries to rip it, intervene immediately. Vets advise that you only allow lick mat use under supervision so you can take it away once the food is gone. This prevents the dog from eating bits of the mat, which could cause choking or an intestinal blockage.

• Replace when worn: Regularly inspect the mat for damage. If you notice pieces missing, deep tooth marks, or cracks, it’s time for a new one. A heavily chewed-up mat could shed bits that end up swallowed. When in doubt, throw it out – they’re not very expensive to replace, and your dog’s safety comes first.

• Tip for heavy chewers: If your dog is a serious chewer (especially some puppies), you may need to take extra precautions or choose alternatives. Some lick mats come with a hard plastic frame or are designed to be more chew-resistant (e.g., with raised edges). You can also try freezing the mat with a thin layer of treat – the hardness of the frozen food sometimes dissuades dogs from biting, as they focus on licking the melt. If your dog consistently tries to chew up lick mats, you might reserve lick mat time for when you can closely watch, or consider using a more durable food puzzle (like a Kong or West Paw Toppl toy) for unsupervised enrichment.

Slow Feeder Bowls for Dogs (Maze Feeding Bowls)

What is a slow feeder bowl? A slow feeder dog bowl looks like a regular pet bowl with a twist – inside the bowl are built-in ridges, bumps, or maze-like shapes that create obstacles for your dog’s tongue as they eat. The goal is to make your dog eat more slowly by turning their meal into a little puzzle. Instead of scarfing down all the food in 10 seconds, the dog has to nudge kibble around the barriers, chasing food into corners or between prongs. This slows their pace of eating to a healthier rate. Slow feeders come in various designs – spirals, concentric ridges, paw-shaped mazes, etc. – and materials (plastic is most common, but some are stainless steel or silicone). They are used at mealtimes in place of a normal food bowl, particularly for dogs who eat too fast.

Benefits of Slow Feeder Bowls

Slow feeder bowls are more than a fad; they have real health and behavioral benefits for dogs who inhale their food. If your canine companion tends to be a “chow hound” or “vacuum cleaner” at dinner, a slow feeder can be a game-changer. Here are the main benefits:

• Prevents choking, gulping & bloat: The primary purpose of a slow feeder is to stop dogs from gulping down food and air, which can cause gagging or even choking. By slowing intake, it also reduces the amount of air swallowed, helping to prevent bloat (gastric dilatation-volvulus) – a life-threatening condition especially in deep-chested breeds. Eating too fast is a risk factor for bloat, so slowing the dog’s eating with a special bowl can literally be lifesaving. Additionally, a slower pace means less regurgitation and vomiting; food has time to settle properly.

• Improved digestion: When a dog wolfs down a meal, the food often isn’t chewed or salivated adequately. Slower eating gives the stomach and intestines time to process food better. Many owners find their dogs burp less and have less gas or post-meal discomfort when using a slow feeder. As one source puts it, “slower eating gives the stomach time to process food properly, reducing the risk of gas, bloating, and discomfort.”

• Weight management: Interestingly, slow feeders can help with portion control and weight management. A dog who eats rapidly might consume their whole portion before their stomach realizes it’s full, begging for more. By stretching out mealtime, the dog’s brain has a chance to catch up with their tummy. They may feel full with the allotted amount of food and be less inclined to beg or overeat. Longer mealtimes can lead to a greater sense of satiety, helping prevent overeating and obesity. (Of course, you still need to measure your dog’s food; a slow bowl just ensures they don’t gobble it too quickly.)

• Mental stimulation: A slow feeder doubles as a simple puzzle toy. Dogs get a mental workout figuring out how to chase kibble around the maze. It’s like turning dinner into a fun little game: “the puzzle-like design adds a layer of mental enrichment to mealtime – think of it as dinner and a game!”. This can make meals more engaging for your dog, providing some enrichment especially for high-energy or intelligent dogs who need extra challenges. It won’t tire them out like a long walk, but it does make them work a bit for their food, tapping into natural foraging instincts.

• Slower, calmer eating habits: Overall, a slow feeder bowl transforms the eating experience from a race into a relaxed routine. Meals last longer – perhaps turning a 1-minute scarf-fest into a 5-10 minute calm dining experience. This can create a more zen-like eater over time. The dog might learn to chew more and not be so frantic at meals. If you have multiple dogs, using slow feeders can also reduce food competition issues, since each dog is focused on their own bowl and can’t finish so fast as to go after a sibling’s portion.

• Better for certain medical conditions: Dogs with conditions like acid reflux may benefit from slower eating to avoid overwhelming the stomach. Also, breeds prone to GDV/bloat (e.g. Great Danes, German Shepherds, Labs) are often recommended by vets to use slow feeders as a preventive measure. While not a guarantee, it’s a simple step that can help lower the risk of a dangerous situation.

Best Foods to Use in Slow Feeder Bowls

Slow feeder bowls are primarily made for dog food – especially dry kibble – but they can actually accommodate a variety of diets:

• Dry kibble: This is the most common use. Just pour your dog’s measured kibble into the slow feeder instead of a normal bowl. The pieces will distribute into the ridges and pockets. Your dog will have to nose and tongue around to get them out, significantly slowing down a kibble gulper. The designs are optimized for dry food to roll around within the maze.

• Wet food: You can use slow feeders with canned food or raw food as well. For canned wet food (pâté or chunks in gravy), you might press it into the grooves or spread it around. Your dog will then lick and maneuver it out, which combines the slow feeding with a bit of licking mat action. Some slow feeder bowls are shallow and work almost like a lick mat for wet food, while others have deeper compartments you can fill. Pro tip: If the wet food is very slippery, a dog might cheat by picking up the whole bowl and trying to tip it – so look for a bowl with non-slip base or suction if using wet food, or be ready to supervise. But generally, yes, slow feeders work for wet food – it will certainly slow the dog compared to slurping from a normal bowl.

• Mixed or soaked food: You can mix kibble with a bit of water or broth and put it in a slow feeder, or do half kibble, half wet. Some slow feeders (like the LickiMat “Slodog” tray) are designed to handle all food types – dry, wet, raw, even liquids – without mess. You can experiment with what works best for your dog. If your dog is on a raw diet (e.g. raw meaty chunks), there are slow feeders that look like muffin trays or have large pockets to place the pieces, forcing the dog to pick them out one by one instead of gulping.

• Frozen meals: Just as you can freeze a lick mat, you can also freeze food in a slow feeder bowl. For example, mix kibble with some water or yogurt, or use a raw/wet mix, and freeze it into the bowl. This effectively turns the slow feeder into a giant ice block treat that the dog has to patiently work on. It’s another way to super-slow a meal and keep a dog busy (and cool on a hot day). Ensure the bowl is freezer-safe if you try this.

In summary, slow feeder bowls are quite versatile – anything you’d feed in a normal bowl can go in a slow feeder, as long as it’s not so liquid that it just spills out. Dry kibble is easiest, but wet and raw can be used too (it might just be a bit messier to clean up).

Choosing & Using a Slow Feeder Bowl (Cleaning, Size & More)

When selecting a slow feeder, consider your dog’s size, face shape, and eating style. Here are some tips to get the most out of it:

• Size & shape for your dog: Pick a slow feeder bowl that suits your dog’s breed and muzzle shape. For example, if you have a short-nosed breed like a Bulldog or Pug, choose a slow feeder with shallow grooves or a more open design; some slow bowls are specifically marketed as brachycephalic-friendly. A dog with a long snout (Collie, Doberman, etc.) can handle deeper maze patterns. Also ensure the bowl holds enough volume for your dog’s meals – large dogs may need an “XL” slow feeder so their full portion fits. Conversely, a tiny dog or puppy might do better with a smaller feeder (big mazes could frustrate a very small dog).

• Material matters: Most slow feeders are plastic, which is lightweight and comes in fun colors/shapes. If choosing plastic, look for BPA-free, food-safe plastic and check that it’s durable (some cheap plastics can crack). There are also stainless steel slow feeder bowls (essentially a metal bowl with a dome in the middle or ridges) – these are very durable and good for dogs who might chew on plastic, and they’re often dishwasher-safe and sanitary. Silicone slow feeders exist too (they’re like floppy mats or bowls) which are quiet (no clinking) and safe but might be easier for a dog to flip or chew if unsupervised. No matter the material, dishwasher-safe is a big plus for convenience.

• Difficulty level: Some slow feeders are very challenging (lots of tight crevices), while others are easier (simple ridges). Match the difficulty to your dog. If your dog has never used a slow feeder, start with a moderately easy design so they don’t get too frustrated or give up. You can even make it easier initially by not filling the bowl completely – let some kibble be more accessible. As they get used to it, you can introduce more complex feeders later if needed. The goal is to slow them down, not to make eating impossible. If you notice your dog getting stressed or whining at the bowl, the design might be too hard – try a simpler one. Dogs that are easily frustrated may do better with a basic slow bowl (just a couple of large ridges) rather than an intricate puzzle.

• Cleaning the bowl: Because of all the crevices, you’ll want to clean the slow feeder after each meal or at least daily. Most are top-rack dishwasher safe, which is the easiest method. If hand washing, use a bottle brush or sponge to get into all the nooks where wet food or slobber might stick. Leftover gunk can spoil the fun fast – residue might mold or attract ants, so keep it clean. If you feed wet food in it, definitely wash promptly as it can get pretty gross if left sitting.

• Non-slip and stability: A common issue is dogs pushing the slow feeder bowl around or flipping it in an attempt to get food out faster. To avoid this, choose one with a non-slip rubber base or suction cups. Some heavy-duty slow feeders even come in a wedge shape or have suction to the floor. You can also place the bowl on a non-skid mat. Supervise initially – if the dog is trying to pick up and drop the bowl to dislodge food, correct that behavior. You may need a heavier or more stable design.

• Patience and training: Introduce the slow feeder when you have time to observe. Encourage your dog as they figure it out – a little cheerleading or a tasty topper (like a drizzle of broth or a few treats) can motivate them. Most dogs get the hang of it quickly, but a few might be resistant at first (“Why is my food trapped?!”). With patience, they’ll adapt. If you truly have a dog that refuses a slow feeder, you can consider other slow-feed methods (like spreading food on a flat pan, using a snuffle mat, or food-dispensing toys). But usually, after a few tries, dogs will use the slow bowl without issue – and some end up loving the challenge.

Now that we’ve covered each tool separately, let’s compare licking mats and slow feeders head-to-head on the key factors that matter to pet owners.

Licking Mat vs Slow Feeder: Feature Comparison

To make your decision easier, here’s a side-by-side comparison of licking mats and slow feeder bowls on important features and uses:

As the table shows, lick mats excel in calming enrichment, flexibility, and treating anxiety or boredom, whereas slow feeder bowls are specialized for slowing down food intake and improving physical health aspects of eating. Next, let’s consider which might be better for your specific dog, because age, personality, and habits matter.

Pros and Cons for Different Dog Types

Every dog is unique. Here we’ll discuss how licking mats vs slow feeders stack up for certain categories of dogs – puppies, seniors, fast eaters, and anxious dogs – including the pros and cons of each product for these groups.

Puppies

Lick Mat for Puppies: A lick mat can be a wonderful tool for puppies. Pros: it provides a quiet, soothing activity to help an overactive or teething puppy calm down. If your puppy is biting everything in sight, redirecting that energy to a yummy lick mat (spread with a little wet food or peanut butter) can keep them occupied and out of trouble. It’s also great for crate training – pup learns to settle in the crate with a lick mat reward, associating the crate with positive, relaxed feelings. Cons: many puppies are enthusiastic chewers, so they might be tempted to chew or pick up the mat. You must supervise; a pup could quickly turn a soft silicone mat into confetti if left alone. Another con is that some very young puppies might not “get” the concept of licking for reward immediately – you may need to guide them or start with an easy spread (something really tasty) to spark their interest. Also, a small lick mat with rich treats could upset a very young pup’s tummy if overused, so introduce slowly.

Slow Feeder for Puppies: If you have a puppy that gulps down kibble like there’s no tomorrow, a slow feeder can be introduced early to encourage better eating habits. Pros: It will prevent the choking/gagging that sometimes happens when puppies eat too fast, and reduce the chance of digestive upset from rapid meals. Slowing a puppy’s eating can also diminish hiccups and burping. It mentally engages a curious pup and can keep them busy a bit longer – helpful if you want to tire them out just a tad. Cons: Some slow feeders might be too difficult for a young puppy with a small mouth. If the ridges are high and the pup is small, they could struggle to reach the food and get frustrated. You may need to get a slow feeder specifically sized for puppies or start with a simple design. Another con is mess: puppies can be messy eaters, and with a slow feeder they might flip the bowl or tip kibble out if they get overly excited. Choose one with a non-slip base and be ready to teach them how to use it. Lastly, if your puppy is actually a grazer (some nibble slowly already), a slow feeder bowl may be unnecessary and could even dissuade them from eating enough – so use it only if you notice speed-eating behavior.

Verdict for Puppies: If your puppy is hyper or anxious at times, a licking mat is fantastic for calming them and teaching self-settling (just watch they don’t chew it). If your puppy eats way too fast and chokes or vomits, a slow feeder bowl is the better choice to slow down mealtime. Many puppy owners find value in both tools: for example, a lick mat to occupy pup during their humans’ dinner time or grooming, and a slow feeder for the pup’s own mealtimes to prevent bad habits. Always supervise puppies with any feeding tool until you’re confident they’re using it safely.

Senior Dogs

Lick Mat for Seniors: Older dogs often have less energy and may not chew hard toys due to dental issues. A lick mat can be a low-impact enrichment that a senior dog finds enjoyable without strain. Pros: It’s gentle – seniors can lick at their own pace without needing to chase or chew. This can be great for a dog with missing teeth or sensitive gums who can’t handle hard chews or kibble as well. It also provides mental stimulation to keep their brain active (cognitive enrichment is helpful for senior dogs to possibly ward off cognitive decline). And it can be calming if a senior is getting anxious in certain situations (some older dogs can get anxious due to vision/hearing loss or dementia; a lick mat might refocus them). Cons: Bending down to the floor might be a bit uncomfortable for a senior with arthritis. You can remedy this by placing the mat on a slightly raised surface or even sticking it to a wall at head height. Another con is if the senior has very reduced appetite; they might not bother with a lick mat unless the food is extra enticing or aromatic. Also, seniors can sometimes be set in their ways – if your old dog has never seen a lick mat, they might be confused by it at first. Generally, though, there are few downsides aside from making sure the ingredients are senior-friendly (for example, moderate the rich peanut butter if weight is a concern).

Slow Feeder for Seniors: For an older dog, you’ll want to decide if slowing their eating is beneficial. Pros: If your senior dog still scarfes food and perhaps is at risk of bloat (common in older large breeds), a slow feeder is certainly useful. It can help their digestion, which might be slower in old age, by preventing overeating too quickly. If your senior tends to throw up from eating fast, this bowl could stop that. Also, some seniors get a bit overweight from lack of exercise – a slow feeder can assist with weight management by making them feel satiated with the proper portion. Cons: Some senior dogs naturally slow down their eating as they age; if that’s the case, a slow bowl might frustrate them or make them eat too little. Dogs with arthritis or neck/spine issues might find it hard to get food out of a deep slow feeder at floor level. You can accommodate this by getting an elevated feeder stand or a shallow maze pattern. Another con is cognitive: if an elderly dog has canine cognitive dysfunction (doggie dementia), they could find a complicated feeder confusing or anxiety-inducing. Always observe – if a senior is struggling or seems upset by the slow feeder, revert to a normal bowl or a simpler solution. Finally, seniors often have more brittle teeth; if the slow feeder is plastic, ensure they don’t try to bite at it and risk a tooth. Most just use their tongue, so it’s usually fine.

Verdict for Seniors: Lick mats are generally a senior-friendly enrichment, as long as the dog shows interest. They’re easy on old mouths and can provide calm engagement. Slow feeders should be used if needed – many older dogs might not need one if they’re already slow eaters or have portion-controlled diets. But for a food-obsessed senior who gulps, the slow bowl can continue to protect them from bloat and indigestion. Consider any physical limitations: for severe arthritis or mobility issues, keep feeding tools simple and accessible (maybe even hand-feed or use a raised dish). In some cases, a lick mat on the wall (so the dog can stand or sit and lick without bending) could be a great solution for arthritic dogs who can’t crouch to eat from a puzzle bowl.

Fast Eaters (Gulpers)

If your dog is known to be a fast eater, you likely already suspect the answer here:

Lick Mat for Fast Eaters: A lick mat can help slow a fast eater only for very small servings or treats. Pros: If you put part of their meal or a snack on a lick mat, it will indeed force them to lick and take more time than just crunching kibble down. In fact, if you feed, say, a few tablespoons of your dog’s kibble by blending it with some wet food and smearing it on a lick mat, it will take longer to consume than the same amount in a bowl. Frozen lick mats in particular can really stretch out eating time, as noted earlier (they “will slow a dog down significantly more than a slow feeder bowl” in some cases). Cons: Lick mats simply do not hold a large volume. If your goal is to slow down a dog’s entire meal (especially for a medium or large dog), a single lick mat likely can’t fit all their food unless you have multiple mats. Also, a very determined fast eater might get frustrated with a lick mat’s limited yield and start chewing or give up once the easy parts are gone. Lick mats are best as an addition, not the sole solution, for a dog that devours meals. They’re awesome for slowing the dog’s treat intake or giving a pre-meal “appetizer” that calms them before the main course, but on their own they may not entirely fix a chronic speed-eating habit if the dog still gets most food in a normal bowl.

Slow Feeder for Fast Eaters: This is really where slow feeder bowls shine. Pros: For a dog that bolts down food, a slow feeder bowl is often the number one recommendation by vets and trainers. It directly tackles the problem by introducing obstacles that force the dog to eat at a measured pace, dramatically reducing gulping. This prevents the cascade of issues (choking, vomiting, farting, bloat, etc.) that come from speed-eating. Most owners of “food gulpers” see an immediate improvement – their dog might go from finishing a meal in 30 seconds to taking 5 minutes or more. That slower pace allows the dog to chew a bit, take breaths, and gives their stomach a chance to fill gradually. Over time, the dog often learns to be a calmer eater in general. Cons: Hardly any, for a fast eater. The main “con” is initial annoyance – some dogs will paw at or flip the slow bowl out of frustration. But with a stable design and a little encouragement, they usually adapt. Another potential con is if the slow feeder is too effective and the dog leaves food because they got bored or frustrated; if that happens, try a slightly easier design so they still get their nutrition. But compared to the risks of fast eating (which include life-threatening bloat in large breeds), these are minor issues.

Verdict for Fast Eaters: Slow feeder bowl, 100%. If your dog scarfs food, start with a slow feeder bowl to immediately mitigate health risks. You can still use a lick mat in addition – for example, as a dessert or a special treat – but it shouldn’t replace a slow feeder for the main meals of a true gulper. One strategy is to use the slow feeder bowl for the bulk of the meal and spread a little of the food on a lick mat or snuffle mat to the side. This gives both enrichment and paced feeding. But if choosing one, go with the slow feeder for fast eaters. It’s a “win-win…easy to use, and can seriously improve your dog’s health, happiness, and quality of life” according to experts when you have a chowhound.

Anxious or High-Energy Dogs

Lick Mat for Anxious/Hyper Dogs: Lick mats are often nicknamed “calming mats” for good reason. Pros: For anxiety, the lick mat is one of the best tools. As discussed, the repetitive licking behavior can help a dog self-soothe and relax. If your dog gets anxious during specific triggers (thunder, fireworks, guests, car rides), giving them a lick mat can redirect their focus to something positive and yummy, thereby lowering their stress. Trainers even use lick mats during behavior modification – e.g., at the vet’s office or during grooming sessions, to create a positive association. Lick mats provide distraction power: the dog is so busy licking that the scary background noise or event is less overwhelming. For high-energy dogs, a lick mat is a good way to simmer them down after exercise. Think of it as a cool-down routine: after a vigorous walk or play, a 10-minute lick mat session in their bed can transition them from high excitement to a calmer state. This is valuable for dogs that have trouble “turning off” after play. Cons: If a dog’s anxiety is extremely high (e.g., severe thunderstorm phobia), sometimes even a favorite food won’t distract them. You might find the dog ignores the lick mat if their stress is off the charts – at that point, additional calming strategies or professional help may be needed. Another con is that not all anxious dogs take to a lick mat automatically; you may need to teach them or experiment with different treats that truly motivate them under stress. In rare cases, an anxious dog could guard a high-value lick mat resource, but that’s more of a training/management issue. Overall, there are few downsides – it’s a low-effort, high-reward tool for calming and occupies the dog in a non-destructive way (versus an anxious dog chewing the couch, for instance).

Slow Feeder for Anxious/Hyper Dogs: A slow feeder bowl isn’t primarily intended for anxiety, but it can play a supporting role. Pros: If part of your dog’s anxious or hyper behavior is related to food (like food obsession, or gulping due to stress), a slow feeder will regulate their eating and could prevent any GI discomfort that might add to anxiety. Also, using a slow feeder is a form of enrichment that can take a little energy or focus, which might help tire out a high-energy dog a bit. For a hyper dog that always seems hungry or dives into meals, the slow feeder ensures they don’t immediately finish and then pester for more food – it occupies them longer, giving you some peace. Cons: On its own, a slow feeder bowl won’t calm an anxious dog during a thunderstorm or help a hyper dog learn to settle. It addresses eating speed, not overall anxiety levels. In fact, if an anxious dog is also a picky eater or has a poor appetite when stressed, making their feeding more challenging could backfire – they might eat even less. Typically, though, if a dog is anxious and a fast eater, you can still use a slow bowl; just pair it with other calming techniques (like a lick mat or calming treats) for the anxiety aspect.

Verdict for Anxious/Easily-Stressed Dogs: The licking mat is the clear winner for directly managing anxiety and hyperactivity. It’s intentionally soothing; many trainers consider it a first line of defense for mild anxiety issues. For interactive dog anxiety relief, a lick mat is often recommended because “licking is said to have a self-soothing effect… ultimately calming them down in stressful situations.” If your dog tends to be anxious or very excitable, start with a lick mat. Meanwhile, use a slow feeder bowl if that same dog also scarfs food or if you want to give them a bit more mental challenge at mealtimes. They address different needs: one emotional, one physical. You can absolutely use both for an anxious dog – for example, a slow feeder at breakfast to keep them busy, and a lick mat later when anxiety triggers happen. But if anxiety is the primary concern, a lick mat should be in your arsenal for sure.

Having weighed the pros and cons for different types of dogs, we can see there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Both licking mats and slow feeders have unique strengths. In many cases, you might benefit from using both in different scenarios. In the next section, we’ll tackle a few frequently asked questions that dog owners have when deciding between a lick mat and a slow feeder.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can I use both a licking mat and a slow feeder bowl for my dog?
A: Absolutely, yes. Lick mats and slow feeders aren’t an either/or proposition – they actually complement each other wonderfully. Each serves a different primary purpose (calming enrichment vs. slowing meals), so using both can give your dog the best of both worlds. For example, you might use a slow feeder bowl every day at dinner to help your dog eat at a healthy pace, and offer a lick mat as an occasional treat or during stressful times for extra enrichment. In fact, experts note that the two tools engage different natural behaviors – “lick mats encourage the sole behavior of licking, while a slow feeder encourages foraging and problem-solving”. Dogs benefit from both types of activity. There’s no conflict in using one at some times and the other at others. Many pet owners keep a slow feeder as their dog’s regular food bowl and also have a couple of lick mats in the cupboard for boredom busters, training aids, or special snacks. So if you can, consider having both on hand. You might even combine them by giving a portion of the meal in the slow bowl and a small portion on a lick mat – turning mealtime into a multi-stage enrichment event!

Q: What if my dog just chews the lick mat instead of licking it?
A: This is a common concern, especially for puppies and heavy chewers. The first thing is always supervise your dog with the lick mat. If they start chewing the mat itself, redirect them to licking the food. You can gently hold the mat or use a mat with suction cups to keep it in place – sometimes mats slide around and dogs try to grab them, so securing the mat can curb the chewing impulse. If a dog continues to try to gnaw, end the session and take the mat away. It’s important they learn that chewing doesn’t get them more reward. Also, consider the type of mat: some lick mats have a firm plastic border or are made of tougher material which can deter dogs from getting an edge up to chew. You could try those if your current mat is too flimsy. Another tip is to freeze the lick mat with the treat on it; a frozen mat takes more focused licking and is harder to chomp on (plus a dog is less likely to view a frozen block as a chew toy). If despite all this your dog still treats the lick mat like a chew toy, you might need to hold off on using it until they’re a bit more mature or use alternative enrichment toys. As Whole Dog Journal suggests, “puppies or dogs who tend to chew should avoid lick mats and opt for Kongs or West Paw Toppl instead”. Those are made of rubber designed to be chewed. You can always reintroduce the lick mat later to see if they’ve learned to just lick. And remember, never leave a dog unsupervised with a lick mat if they are prone to chewing – pieces of torn mat could be swallowed and cause harm. With consistent guidance, many dogs will learn the licking mat routine and stop trying to munch it, but always err on the side of safety.

Q: When should I avoid using a lick mat or slow feeder?
A: For the most part, these tools are very dog-friendly, but there are a few situations where they might not be appropriate:

• Avoid lick mats with unsupervised heavy chewers: As discussed, if your dog is likely to destroy and ingest a lick mat, don’t give it to them in situations where you can’t supervise. In such cases, a durable chew toy might be better for alone time. Also, if your dog has shown zero interest in lick mats (some rare dogs aren’t food-motivated enough to bother), forcing it isn’t necessary.

• Avoid slow feeders for dogs who don’t need them: If your dog naturally eats slowly or is a very picky eater, a slow feeder could further reduce their food intake or frustrate them. Forcing a poor eater to work for food might cause them to eat less. Also, extremely small or young puppies who haven’t learned to eat kibble well might struggle with a slow feeder – wait until they’re a bit bigger or more adept at eating. In short, don’t use a slow bowl “just because” if your dog is fine with a regular bowl and has no issues. Use it when there’s a problem to solve (fast eating, etc.).

• For Brachycephalic (flat-faced) breeds: Avoid slow feeders that are too intricate or deep. These breeds (e.g., Pugs, Bulldogs, Shih Tzus) can have a hard time getting food out of tight corners due to their short snouts. If you notice your flat-faced dog struggling or scraping their face, switch to a more shallow slow feeder or even use a lick mat or large platter-style feeder which is easier for them. The goal is to slow them, not torture them! Many flat-faced dogs do well with slow feeders designed for them (with wide channels).

• When a dog is extremely hungry or low on patience: If your dog is overly hungry (maybe you’re feeding a bit late) and gets panicky or aggressive when eating, a slow feeder could initially trigger some frustration or resource guarding. In such cases, you might avoid the slow feeder at that moment or use a gentler design to prevent any food aggression incidents. Similarly, if your dog is ill or low energy and needs easy access to food, a slow feeder might be too much work – a simple bowl might be kinder while they recover.

• Messy or outdoor scenarios for lick mats: If you’re in a situation where a messy treat would be a problem (say, at a carpeted friend’s house or in the car without protection), a lick mat with smearable food could cause a mess if the dog picks it up or drags it. You might avoid using it there unless you have a way to secure it (like suction to a car window or using it in a crate).

In summary, avoid using either tool if it clearly causes your dog frustration, stress, or physical difficulty. Always observe how your dog responds. Most dogs adapt well, but if yours shows signs of anxiety or anger with a slow feeder (growling at it, etc.) or tries to eat the actual lick mat, reconsider your approach. There’s always another method or a different design that might suit your pup better.

Conclusion: Buying Guide Summary – How to Choose the Best Option for Your Dog

Both licking mats and slow feeder bowls can improve your dog’s life in different ways, so the choice ultimately depends on your dog’s age, breed, behavior, and eating style. Here’s a quick summary to help you decide:

• If your dog is a voracious, fast eater (the type who finishes a meal in seconds and might gag or bloat): Start with a slow feeder bowl. This is the best tool to immediately slow down their eating for health reasons. Look for one sized appropriately (bigger dogs need larger bowls) and with a maze design that isn’t too easy (you want to significantly stretch their eating time, but not so hard they give up). A slow feeder will promote better digestion and could save your dog from serious issues like bloat. You can always get a lick mat as an extra for treats, but the slow feeder should be your go-to for daily meals.

• If your dog struggles with anxiety, stress, or boredom (e.g., gets nervous during storms, has separation anxiety, or is overly hyper): Incorporate a licking mat. Lick mats are an inexpensive, effective way to provide dog anxiety relief and enrichment. Use it to distract and calm your dog during triggering events – many owners see their anxious dog visibly relax when engaged with a lick mat. For a high-energy dog, give a lick mat after exercise or in the evening to help them wind down. While you might also use a slow feeder for such a dog (especially if they eat fast too), the lick mat is the star for emotional well-being.

• For a puppy: You might want both, used judiciously. Use a slow feeder bowl if your puppy is eating too quickly and/or to teach good habits from the start. Use a lick mat for crate training, quiet time, or during puppy’s first baths to make them positive (smear something tasty so pup associates the bath with yummy licking). Remember to supervise and choose puppy-safe designs (shallow slow feeder, durable lick mat). Many puppy owners report that a lick mat was a sanity-saver for keeping a young pup occupied for a few minutes. Just be ready to intervene if chewing starts.

• For a senior dog: Consider their specific needs. If your senior has become a picky or slow eater, a slow feeder bowl might be unnecessary – in fact, give them whatever bowl makes eating easiest. But if your senior still woofs down food and has a risk of bloat or indigestion, absolutely keep using a slow feeder. For enrichment, a lick mat can be wonderful for a senior – it’s low effort and enjoyable, and can encourage water intake if you use moist foods (great for seniors who need hydration). Make sure the design is accessible (maybe elevate it or use a mat with larger grooves). Many senior dogs, even with some cognitive decline, find simple pleasure in a lick mat treat.

• Breed considerations: Large, deep-chested breeds (Great Dane, German Shepherd, etc.) – slow feeder is highly recommended due to bloat risk. Brachycephalic (Bulldog, Pug) – lick mat or specialized slow feeder; avoid deep mazes that their short snouts can’t navigate. Smart working breeds (Border Collie, Poodle, etc.) – they might love the challenge of a slow feeder and benefit from the calming lick mat, so having both to alternate could keep them nicely occupied. Tiny breeds (Chihuahua, etc.) – a lick mat might double as a slow feeder for them since their meals are so small, or get a mini slow feeder.

• If your goal is purely enrichment and keeping your dog busy (and they have no eating speed issues): You could lean towards a licking mat or other puzzle toys first. Slow feeders do provide enrichment, but if your dog doesn’t need slower eating, a treat puzzle or lick mat might be more exciting for them. Some people use slow feeders as easy puzzles regardless – that’s fine, just ensure your dog actually enjoys it and isn’t bored by it.

• If your goal is primarily health (digestion, weight): Go with the slow feeder bowl. For dogs on diets, making them eat slower can help them feel fuller, and it ties directly to physical health improvements (less gas, less reflux, etc.). Lick mats are more of a bonus in the health department (except maybe dental minor benefits and stress reduction).

Finally, remember that both products are relatively inexpensive and widely available, so you don’t have to limit yourself to one if your dog could use both types of stimulation. Many dogs will get the most benefit from having a slow feeder and a lick mat in their routine – one to make mealtimes safer and one to enrich their down time. As one dog enrichment specialist put it, providing novel ways for dogs to “work” for their food is extremely beneficial to their well-being. Lick mats and slow feeders are easy ways to do just that.

Buying tip: Read reviews and consider your dog’s personality when choosing a specific product. Some lick mats have different textures (soft vs. firm), and some slow bowls are more complex than others. If possible, start with simpler designs and graduate to more complex if needed – ensuring your dog always has fun and stays safe using them.

In conclusion, choose a licking mat if you want a versatile tool for treats, training, and calming enrichment – it’s great for anxious, bored, or chew-prone dogs that need a gentle activity. Choose a slow feeder bowl if your dog eats too quickly and you want to protect their health and improve their digestion – it’s a must for any dog prone to gulping or bloating. And if those both describe your dog, go ahead and get one of each. Your furry friend will enjoy the tasty challenge, and you’ll enjoy seeing them happier, healthier, and more satisfied. Happy feeding time, and here’s to wagging tails and calmer tummies!

Enrique

Hi, I am the author of this article. For the past 10 years or so, we have been dedicated to meeting the custom silicone product needs of our customers from over 50 countries and regions around the world.

If you have any questions, please contact us for a free, no-obligation quote.